Insure and be Sure

1-800-416-7655

In Business Since 1920

Pay Tobey & Merrill Online


Make A PaymentTobey & Merrill Insurance is now offering our valued customers the ability to make online check payments through our secure website.

Pay by Online CheckClick Here to make a Vcheck payment to Tobey & Merrill Insurance Agency.


Please be advised that submitting an electronic check "DOES NOT" constitute receipt of payment, nor does it bind any insurance coverage until either written or verbal confirmation by Tobey & Merrill Insurance. 

Pay the Insurance Company Directly.  

At Tobey & Merrill Insurance we understand our clients lifestyles require alternative methods for remitting payments and we pride ourselves by representing carriers who understand this need. Although most of these alternatives are listed on the carrier invoice, here are some of the methods that your carrier may have available.   

  • Pay By Phone or On-Line
  • Credit Card
  • ATM Debit Card
  • ACH/Electronic Check   

How to make a payment:

Have the following information ready and select your carrier from the list provided.   

For Credit Card or ATM Payments:  

  • Your policy number located on your invoice or statement
  • Your Credit Card or ATM Card  

 For payment using your Checking Account:  

  • Your policy number located on your invoice or statement
  • The routing number and checking account number. The routing number is the 9-digit identifier that is located between two symbols on the bottom-left hand side of the check. Your checking account number immediately follows your bank's routing number as the second set of numbers.  

Insurance Companies:

If your carrier is not listed on our partners page, please contact Tobey & Merrill at 1-800-416-7655