Insure and be Sure


In Business Since 1920


It’s Fast, It’s Easy and It’s Free  

Get A QuoteAs an Independent Insurance Agency, Tobey & Merrill Insurance offers a variety of insurance products customized to your individual needs.   We have partnered with several AM Best® Top Rated Regional and National Insurance Companies in order to offer you the best combination of Price, Coverage and Service.    Let's get started on your Free Quote from Tobey & Merrill Insurance....  

Best Quote Option

Tobey & Merrill “Personalized” Quote Request (Includes all eligible discounts and credits)  


Basic Quote Option

Online Comparative Quote (Does not include all “eligible” discounts and credits)


Specialty Products and more...

We have products for Antique Autos, Recreational Vehicles, Coastal Property, Mobile Homes, Rental Property, Contractors, Special Events and more… We offer discounts for multi-car, multi-policies, safe drivers, mature operators, good-students, security systems, EFT, loss free, accident free and more... Don’t see what you need, Tobey & Merrill has access to Specialty and Alternative Insurance Markets,

Contact Us for more information.  

Everything In One Place, Now That's The Key